Why Marvel’s Phase 5 Movies Feel Different From the Original Plan
Marvel’s Phase 5 was expected to provide a clear path through the Multiverse Saga. After Avengers: Endgame, audiences were looking for the next major villain, a new generation of heroes, and a storyline that could match the scale of the Infinity Saga. The early signs pointed toward Kang, the Young Avengers, and a steadily expanding network of alternate realities.
The films released during this phase have created a different impression. Some have pushed the Marvel Cinematic Universe toward stranger genres, older characters, and more self-contained stories. Others have exposed the difficulty of maintaining a shared universe when audiences are not equally invested in every new hero or streaming series.
That change does not necessarily mean the MCU has lost its direction. Instead, Phase 5 has revealed a franchise adjusting in public. Marvel Studios has had to respond to box-office pressure, changing audience habits, production delays, and the removal of Jonathan Majors from the role of Kang. The result is a phase that feels less like a straight road to the next Avengers movie and more like a period of creative correction.
The Kang-Centered Roadmap Has Lost Its Certainty
When Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania arrived in 2023, it appeared to be a major launch point for Marvel’s next saga. The movie introduced Kang the Conqueror as a powerful multiversal threat and ended with the suggestion that countless versions of the character could become future Avengers villains. Its position as the first Phase 5 movie made the message clear: the Kang Dynasty was supposed to be the central engine of the MCU.
The response was much less enthusiastic than Marvel likely expected. Although Kang remained an imposing presence, the film’s visual effects, humor, and story received a mixed reception. Its box-office performance was also weaker than many previous Marvel premieres. Rather than creating immediate excitement for a new overarching villain, Quantumania made the long-term plan look more vulnerable.
Jonathan Majors’ legal troubles and subsequent departure from Marvel changed that equation entirely. The studio ultimately moved away from its previously announced Avengers: The Kang Dynasty direction, with the project becoming Avengers: Doomsday and Robert Downey Jr. returning as Doctor Doom. That is a significant creative shift. The multiverse remains relevant, but the face of the saga has changed from a rising new antagonist to a familiar performer in a radically different role.
The Films Are Less Dependent On A Single Formula
Earlier MCU phases generally trained viewers to expect a recognizable pattern: introduce a hero, connect the story to the larger universe, add a post-credits scene, and build toward a crossover. Phase 5 movies have followed that structure inconsistently. Some function as direct franchise chapters, while others feel like genre experiments with only loose connections to the larger saga.
Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 is a strong example. It is tied to the broader MCU, but its emotional power comes from the Guardians’ own history. James Gunn focused on Rocket’s traumatic past, the team’s changing relationships, and the possibility that this version of the group might be ending. The film works because it treats a smaller character family as the main event rather than using them as another piece on the way to Secret Wars.
The Marvels takes a different approach by combining Captain Marvel, Ms. Marvel, and Monica Rambeau. Its body-swapping action sequences, musical planet, and brisk comedy make it one of the more unusual MCU entries. At the same time, the film depends heavily on knowledge from WandaVision, Ms. Marvel, and the first Captain Marvel. That connection demonstrates both the potential and the risk of Marvel’s cross-platform storytelling: dedicated viewers get a layered crossover, while casual moviegoers may feel that essential context is missing.
Phase 5 Has Become More Genre-Driven
The most unexpected feature of this phase is its range of tones. The movies do not all look or feel like variations of the same superhero adventure. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 is a tearful science-fiction farewell. Deadpool & Wolverine is an R-rated comedy built around violence, celebrity cameos, and the history of 20th Century Fox’s Marvel films. Captain America: Brave New World leans into political tension, government power, and the legacy of Steve Rogers, even while delivering a conventional superhero conflict.
This variety gives Marvel a chance to reach different audiences. Deadpool & Wolverine succeeded partly because it offered something that the MCU had rarely delivered in theaters: an adult-oriented, aggressively irreverent event movie. Its appeal came from Ryan Reynolds and Hugh Jackman, but also from the collision between the modern MCU and the older Fox universe. The film treated superhero continuity as both story material and comedy, turning years of franchise history into part of the entertainment.
The approach also shows that Marvel no longer has to make every project feel interchangeable. A cosmic family drama, a legacy sequel, and a political action film can all exist under the same studio banner. The challenge is ensuring that variety still contributes to a meaningful larger identity. Genre experimentation can refresh the franchise, but it can also make Phase 5 appear scattered when no central storyline dominates.
| Phase 5 movie | Primary appeal | Connection to the wider MCU | What makes it different |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania | Quantum Realm adventure and Kang setup | Introduces a major multiversal threat | Attempts to launch a saga through a smaller hero |
| Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 | Emotional character drama | Continues the Guardians’ cosmic storyline | Prioritizes closure over franchise expansion |
| The Marvels | Superhero team-up and fast comedy | Links three separate hero stories | Relies heavily on both films and streaming series |
| Deadpool & Wolverine | R-rated humor and legacy cameos | Connects the MCU with Fox’s Marvel universe | Makes continuity itself part of the joke |
| Captain America: Brave New World | Political action and superhero conflict | Extends the Captain America legacy | Centers Sam Wilson’s leadership rather than Steve Rogers |
| Thunderbolts* | Antihero ensemble and redemption | Brings several secondary characters together | Reframes damaged or morally gray heroes as a team |
Legacy Characters Are Carrying More Weight
Phase 5 has revealed how much Marvel still depends on established characters. Sam Wilson’s Captain America, Carol Danvers, the Guardians, Deadpool, and Wolverine all carry more immediate recognition than many of the newer heroes introduced after Endgame. Even when the studio promotes the future, its most reliable theatrical draws remain connected to the past.
That reliance is especially visible in Deadpool & Wolverine. Wolverine’s return was a major event because Hugh Jackman had already made the role iconic. The movie could generate excitement before audiences knew its full story because the character had decades of cultural recognition. Deadpool also brought an established fan base from two successful Fox films. Their appearance gave the multiverse concept an emotional and commercial hook that newer alternate-reality characters have struggled to match.
Sam Wilson’s story presents a different kind of legacy. Captain America: Brave New World is not simply another sequel; it asks whether a new hero can carry the symbolic weight of a title associated with Steve Rogers. The film’s importance therefore comes from character succession as much as action. Marvel is increasingly exploring what happens after the original icons step aside, rather than pretending the transition can happen without friction.
The Streaming Era Has Complicated Movie Stories
Marvel’s theatrical plans can no longer be separated from Disney+ as easily as they were during the Infinity Saga. Characters and plotlines move between movies and series, and the amount of required viewing has become a significant issue for audiences. A viewer watching The Marvels may benefit from knowing Kamala Khan’s story in Ms. Marvel and Monica Rambeau’s development in WandaVision, while someone watching Brave New World may encounter consequences connected to The Falcon and the Winter Soldier.
This interconnected design can reward committed fans, but it weakens the idea that every film is an accessible event for the general public. The earlier Avengers movies created anticipation by bringing together characters viewers already knew from successful films. Phase 5 has often asked audiences to invest in characters across different formats before their movie appearances become important.
Marvel appears to be responding by reducing the number of projects and placing greater emphasis on individual theatrical releases. That shift may help restore a sense of occasion. A smaller schedule gives each film more room to establish its identity, receive focused marketing, and avoid being buried under a constant stream of superhero content.
The Multiverse Is Now A Tool Rather Than The Whole Story
The multiverse remains one of Phase 5’s defining ideas, but its function has changed. At first, alternate timelines seemed to be the foundation of the next grand narrative. By the time Deadpool & Wolverine arrived, the concept worked more effectively as a way to revisit abandoned franchises, combine different eras, and explore fan expectations.
That may be a healthier role for the concept. Multiverse storytelling can become confusing when every universe, variant, and branching timeline is treated as equally important. It becomes more engaging when used for a specific purpose, such as examining the relationship between Deadpool and Wolverine or allowing Marvel to acknowledge the history of Fox’s superhero films.
The challenge for future Avengers projects will be creating emotional stakes that do not depend entirely on continuity puzzles. Endgame succeeded because viewers cared about the characters before the time travel and alternate realities appeared. Marvel’s next crossover will need to make its audience care about the people facing the crisis, not just the mechanics of the crisis itself.
What This Means For The Next Marvel Era
Phase 5 is shaping the MCU differently because it has weakened the assumption that every release must serve one predetermined master plan. Marvel still has a broad direction involving the multiverse, major crossover films, and new versions of classic heroes. However, the route has become more flexible and reactive than the studio’s original announcements suggested.
The change could benefit the franchise. A more adaptable Marvel Studios can respond to audience reactions, give filmmakers greater freedom, and stop forcing every character into the same formula. It can also use its enormous history more thoughtfully, treating legacy heroes as meaningful figures rather than simple nostalgia triggers.
The risk is fragmentation. If the studio moves from Kang to Doctor Doom, from new heroes to returning icons, and from cosmic stories to political thrillers without a strong emotional through line, audiences may stop viewing the MCU as one connected experience. Marvel does not need every movie to look alike, but each release should make the larger universe feel worthwhile.
Releases Worth Watching Closely
- Follow how Sam Wilson’s Captain America develops as a leader separate from Steve Rogers.
- Pay attention to whether Doctor Doom becomes a compelling character rather than only a replacement for Kang.
- Watch for stronger links between theatrical films and Disney+ series without requiring extensive homework.
- Compare new superhero teams with the original Avengers to see whether their relationships feel earned.
- Track whether Marvel’s upcoming movies prioritize distinct genres while preserving a clear emotional direction.
The most interesting question surrounding Phase 5 is no longer whether Marvel can repeat the formula that led to Endgame. It is whether the MCU can evolve without losing the character connections that made that formula successful. The movies released so far suggest that Marvel is testing a broader range of tones, relying on legacy figures, and rebuilding its long-term plan after several unexpected disruptions.
Follow Roses On Paper for continuing coverage of Marvel movies, streaming releases, superhero news, entertainment reviews, and the next developments in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.